Connect with us

HTML Image


Breaking News

Pro-Russia edits at RNZ may have been happening for years



An RNZ digital journalist who allegedly inserted pro-Russian sentiment into news stories claims they have edited reports in that way for five years and nobody queried it.

The public broadcaster is launching a review after it said it found out on Friday that stories were being altered to give them a pro-Russian slant.

That was despite concerns being raised about the journalist’s work more than a year ago. They have now been placed on leave.

So far, 250 stories have been reviewed and 16 have had to be corrected.

RNZ management has conceded the broadcaster’s process for publishing stories from other media companies has not been strong enough, and there will be an external review of editorial processes.

“I subbed several stories that way over the past number of years,” the journalist told Checkpoint.

“In fact since I started RNZ and… I have done that for five years and nobody has tapped me on the shoulder and told me that I was doing anything wrong.”

Checkpoint reported that those claims had not yet been verified by the staff member’s managers.

An important distinction
RNZ chief executive and editor-in-chief Paul Thompson told Checkpoint, in response to the staff member’s claims that no issues were raised about editing for years, that those comments appeared to be about the staffer’s overall role as a sub-editor.

“The job of a sub-editor is to improve stories, add context, improve the journalism. What we’re talking about here is a very small proportion of stories where something quite different happened, where incorrect and misleading information was inserted into wire copy. So it’s important to make that distinction.”

Thompson described the altered copy as “pro-Kremlin garbage”.

“We’re feeling shocked and stunned and really, really challenged by this,” he told Checkpoint.

Thompson said there was an employment process underway in relation to the RNZ staff member.

“What’s happened is a serious breach of our editorial standards and personally, I’m just so gutted by it.

“We’ve let our audience down, and the Ukrainian community down, but I do need to make sure that we have a robust process because we’ve got enough challenges on our plate at the moment, I don’t want to compound that by getting ahead of a fair process.”

He said the audit had not yet found examples of inappropriate edits outside of Ukraine-Russia stories.

“I would point out that it is confined to one area… they’re still serious, I’m not diminishing it at all.

“We’ve done a really good look to make sure that we have a good feel for the range of the problems and I’m confident they’re confined to this one area.”

Thompson said senior staff from both the digital and wider news team were involved in the audit.

They were the right people for the job as they knew how the system worked, he said.

“What they’re doing is getting to the bottom of the audit and looking at every story and I’m confident in that process and it’s being done very well and very robustly,” Thompson said.

The independent review would look at robustness of processes around editing of stories for the website. The findings would be “very challenging” and they would be made public, he said.

“I think that is the best path to making sure any other issues are surfaced.”

In May 2022, serious concerns were raised about the same RNZ staff member’s work in a story written about Russia.

Thompson said the story received additional content and editing which met editorial standards.

“We did review the story at the time and … the story was changed to meet our editorial standards so our systems actually worked at the time.”

Thompson said the journalist was notified.

Thompson said he had not made any decisions yet on changing the editorial structure of RNZ as a result.

“I think that will be something I will be reflecting on and I’ll be looking to do anything which can make a positive difference, because we need to get to the bottom of this and we need to improve things.”

Thompson said he had not offered his resignation over the matter, nor had anyone else in management.

The independent review will report to the board and provide any advice to them.

Public confidence ‘eroded’
RNZ board chairperson Jim Mather told Checkpoint the actions of the staff member who inserted pro-Russian sentiment into web copy published on the RNZ website had “eroded” public confidence in the broadcaster.

He said he was extremely disappointed on behalf of the board. Mather said RNZ was a taonga, with 98 years of history as trusted public media.

“The role the board is going to take is we are going to appoint the panel of trusted individuals, experienced journalists, those that do have editorial experience to undertake the review. This is going to be done completely separate from the other work being undertaken by management,” he said.

They would leave “no stone unturned”.

“This is one of those times when the board needs to step up into this role, and we have undertaken that.” They would meet on Tuesday to decide the terms of reference.

Mather said the board maintained confidence in RNZ’s chief executive. He said the board was working closely with the chief executive to ensure a robust and transparent process was undertaken.

As for the story in 2022 which first attracted attention over its apparent lack of balance, Mather said it “should have given rise to measures being taken to ensure that highly topical issue was being closely monitored in terms of editorial standards”.

“I certainly have judgement about the systems that we have in place, and I am going to await the findings of the review in terms of the judgement of management around the whole issue”.

“But clearly at this point our systems are not adequate, or proven not to be adequate emphatically… it should raise questions about, why was this not identified at an earlier point in time?”

He said RNZ had a “massive challenge” ahead to win back the public’s confidence.

“We pride ourselves as having the highest standards of journalistic quality, so I can say it’s had a significant impact also on our journalism team. I think coming back from this issue is going to take a lot of work. Trust is… hard-fought and hard-earned, but easily lost.”



Continue Reading
Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Breaking News

Roadworker drove stolen digger through town to steal ATM from Wainuiomata BP



Luke Randall drove a stolen digger through town to a petrol station where he attempted to steal an ATM machine but instead caused $170,000 in damages before running off.

Around 1.30am on May 16 last year, Randall, 35, drove to a K&D Contracting worksite on Queen St in Wainuiomata, a site owned by his father.

There, he removed temporary fencing, entered the yard and broke the lock to a Hitachi seven-tonne excavator.

After turning it on with an unknown tool, he drove the industrial machine across two lanes of traffic toward the BP service station forecourt on Wainuiomata Rd, before parking himself directly in front of the station’s ATM.

Randall used the “boom arm” of the excavator to smash windows and crush the roof of the service station before causing further damage in an attempt to get the ATM.

But about two minutes later, he jumped out of the digger and ran off.

Today, the roadworker appeared in the Wellington District Court where he faced sentencing on charges of unlawfully taking the excavator and burglary. A charge of wilful damage has been withdrawn.

Judge Bruce Davidson noted the $170,000 worth of damage he caused and described the series of events as “quite spectacular” and “dramatic”.

Crown prosecutor Rachel Buckman said the amount of reparation sought by the business was $170,844, but accepted ” couple thousand dollars could be realistic” for the newly employed man.

Buckman said a sentence of home detention was “in the realm” of an appropriate outcome for Randall.

“The level of damage done was extraordinary in this case and needs to be taken seriously with a punitive element,” she said.

Defence lawyer Lara Caris said there was a clear nexus between her client’s addiction issues and his offending.

She said steps towards rehabilitation and a new job in traffic management had set him on a better path.

Judge Davidson acknowledged that pre-sentence reports had shown his willingness to confront his substance issues.

He said a sentence of home detention would allow Randall’s counselling and employment to continue.

Randall was sentenced to 10 months of home detention and ordered to pay $3000 of the $170,844 in reparation.

“Although it is only a token of reparation sought, I have to approach the issue with realism and pragmatism,” Judge Davidson said.

This story originally appeared in the New Zealand Herald.

Continue Reading

Breaking News

Multiple houses on fire in Māngere Bridge, homes evacuated



Firefighters from across Auckland are attempting to control a large blaze on Coronation Rd in Māngere Bridge.

Five structures have been completely destroyed and multiple houses have been evacuated.

Emergency services were first called just before 3am to the blaze, which is close to the BP and church opposite Black Bridge Reserve.

Several road blocks were in place manned by fire and police, with a stretch of Coronation Rd closed between Walmsley Rd and the Coronation Rd off-ramp to State Highway 20.

Fire and Emergency northern shift manager Gareth Lewis said multiple calls had come in from 2.58am about a house fire in the suburb.

“On arrival, we found multiple houses well involved in fire,” he said.

Just after 5am the blaze was at a third alarm, with 14 fire trucks in attendance including three ladder trucks and three specialist appliances.


Continue Reading

Breaking News

Employment Relations Authority asked to step in over senior doctor pay dispute



Te Whatu Ora is asking the Employment Relations Authority to step in and help resolve its pay dispute with senior doctors and dentists.

More than 5000 members of the Association of Salaried Medical Specialists (ASMS) are set to walk of the job for the third time on Thursday after last ditch talks on Tuesday ended in an impasse.

Te Whatu Ora chief executive Margie Apa said the agency had urged the union to join it in applying to the ERA for facilitated bargaining.

“We are disappointed that ASMS did not join us in this initiative but remain committed to doing all we can to resolve this dispute.

“We continue to urge the union executive to formally present the current offer to their membership.”

No caption

Te Whatu Ora chief executive Margie Apa. Photo: RNZ / Samuel Rillstone

The union said there had been no movement from Te Whatu Ora on its salary claim since it previously took the offer to members.

Its spokesperson said the offer on the table failed to even match inflation, and amounted to a pay cut for senior doctors and dentists for the third year in a row.

‘Hospitals are currently short more than 1700 senior doctors and specialists (about 20-25 percent) with that work being performed by the current staff.

“This is contributing to burnout and exasperating doctors wanting to leave the public system for private practice or overseas.

“Increasing the salary levels to not have them effectively go backwards will assist in the recruitment and retention of senior medical specialists.”

Te Whatu Ora said its teams were still determining the impact of the strike, but it was likely up to 250 operations, procedures and specialist appointments would be deferred.

Meanwhile, senior doctors and dentists from Auckland hospitals are using their four-hour strike on Thursday to fundraise for Lifeline.

Staff from Auckland, Starship, Waitākere, North Shore, Greenlane and Middlemore hospitals along with community mental health will gather at Pukekawa / Auckland Domain at 11am.

The union will also make a donation to Lifeline in recognition of Mental Health Awareness Week.



Continue Reading


Copyright © 2022 The Buzz: Powered by Apna Network Limited - Concept by Digital Hub NZ