{"id":18918,"date":"2026-11-18T05:52:23","date_gmt":"2026-11-17T16:52:23","guid":{"rendered":"https:\/\/thebuzz.apnanetwork.co.nz\/?p=18918"},"modified":"2026-11-18T05:52:23","modified_gmt":"2026-11-17T16:52:23","slug":"not-the-way-mmp-was-supposed-to-work-experts-urge-politicians-to-act-on-overhang","status":"publish","type":"post","link":"https:\/\/thebuzz.apnanetwork.co.nz\/?p=18918","title":{"rendered":"&#8216;Not the way MMP was supposed to work&#8217;: Experts urge politicians to act on overhang"},"content":{"rendered":"<div class=\"font-serif-text mb-12 leading-normal\">\n<p class=\"[&amp;_em]:font-serif-text-italic [&amp;_cite]:font-serif-text-italic\">A group of 46 experts wants politicians to urgently consider improving the MMP electoral system, to avoid undemocratic elections in future.<\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div class=\"font-serif-text mb-12 leading-normal\">\n<p class=\"[&amp;_em]:font-serif-text-italic [&amp;_cite]:font-serif-text-italic\">Their open letter &#8211; led by Andrew Geddis, Lara Greaves and Max Rashbrooke &#8211; is titled &#8220;Keep the &#8216;P&#8217; in MMP&#8221; and points to <a class=\"underline-brand-hover visited:text-foreground-secondary hover:visited:text-foreground-primary\" href=\"https:\/\/www.rnz.co.nz\/news\/politics_election-2026\/2523978\/parliamentary-service-working-on-extra-chairs-and-offices-for-increased-number-of-mps\">the 11-seat overhang<\/a> indicated by the initial results putting the proportionality the &#8216;P&#8217; stands for at risk.<\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div class=\"font-serif-text mb-12 leading-normal\">\n<p class=\"[&amp;_em]:font-serif-text-italic [&amp;_cite]:font-serif-text-italic\">&#8220;I don&#8217;t think it&#8217;s how people want MMP to work,&#8221; Rashbrooke told RNZ. &#8220;People should be speaking out on it and trying to underline for MPs the urgency of tackling it, and try and find a bipartisan solution.&#8221;<\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div class=\"font-serif-text mb-12 leading-normal\">\n<p class=\"[&amp;_em]:font-serif-text-italic [&amp;_cite]:font-serif-text-italic\">Geddis said the four-seat overhang for Te P\u0101ti M\u0101ori was the result of a <a class=\"underline-brand-hover visited:text-foreground-secondary hover:visited:text-foreground-primary\" href=\"https:\/\/www.rnz.co.nz\/news\/politics_election-2026\/1872528\/just-politics-or-the-opposite-of-clever-the-risks-and-rewards-of-strategic-voting\">deliberate campaign to expand influence<\/a> well beyond its party vote entitlement, and despite campaigns calling for the same thing <a class=\"underline-brand-hover visited:text-foreground-secondary hover:visited:text-foreground-primary\" href=\"https:\/\/www.rnz.co.nz\/news\/politics_election-2026\/2501563\/disproportional-representation-what-national-wins-and-loses-from-the-overhang\">National&#8217;s seven overhang seats<\/a> were &#8220;more like an organic result of the National Party continuing to do reasonably well in individual electorates, while its party vote fell off&#8221;.<\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div class=\"font-serif-text mb-12 leading-normal\">\n<p class=\"[&amp;_em]:font-serif-text-italic [&amp;_cite]:font-serif-text-italic\">Overall, the result distorted representation in Parliament, and he pointed to the &#8217;78 and &#8217;81 elections that delivered National governments despite Labour winning more votes. That mismatch was &#8220;one of the reasons we actually shifted to MMP&#8221;.<\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div class=\"font-serif-text mb-12 leading-normal\">\n<p class=\"[&amp;_em]:font-serif-text-italic [&amp;_cite]:font-serif-text-italic\">&#8220;The overhang could well deliver the same outcome, where you have three parties that have a majority of the seats in the House, but receive fewer votes across the country than the other four parties in Parliament.<\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div class=\"font-serif-text mb-12 leading-normal\">\n<p class=\"[&amp;_em]:font-serif-text-italic [&amp;_cite]:font-serif-text-italic\">&#8220;Not really the way democracy is supposed to work, and it&#8217;s definitely not the way MMP was supposed to work&#8221;.<\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div class=\"pb-16 pt-8\">\n<div class=\"grid justify-center\">\n<figure class=\"mx-auto table\">\n<div class=\"image-ring flex w-full max-w-full -mx-16 md:mx-0 w-screen border-x-0 !max-w-[initial] md:w-[revert-layer] md:!max-w-full [&amp;_img]:w-full [&amp;_img]:md:w-[revert-layer]\"><img loading=\"lazy\" decoding=\"async\" class=\"ml:max-h-[50rem] max-w-full aspect-[16\/10] object-cover\" src=\"https:\/\/media.rnztools.nz\/rnz\/image\/upload\/s--Or8Reecl--\/t_kt-crop-16x10\/w_614\/f_auto\/q_auto:eco\/4JWMKWX_Andrew_Geddis_website_photo_1300x760_png\" alt=\"Andrew Geddis is a law professor at University of Otago.\" width=\"614\" height=\"384\" \/><\/div><figcaption class=\"border-stroke-default w-full border-b py-12 text-sm *:inline table-caption caption-bottom mt-auto\">Andrew Geddis.<\/p>\n<p class=\"text-foreground-secondary flex-shrink-0 ml-4\">Supplied<\/p>\n<\/figcaption><\/figure>\n<\/div>\n<\/div>\n<div class=\"font-serif-text mb-12 leading-normal\">\n<p class=\"[&amp;_em]:font-serif-text-italic [&amp;_cite]:font-serif-text-italic\">Rashbrooke warned it could also become the norm in future.<\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div class=\"font-serif-text mb-12 leading-normal\">\n<p class=\"[&amp;_em]:font-serif-text-italic [&amp;_cite]:font-serif-text-italic\">&#8220;Now that people have seen that it is at least <a class=\"underline-brand-hover visited:text-foreground-secondary hover:visited:text-foreground-primary\" href=\"https:\/\/www.rnz.co.nz\/news\/politics_election-2026\/2486133\/a-lot-to-answer-for-chris-bishop-slams-vote-splitting-campaigns-as-he-farewells-parliament\">possible to engineer an overhang<\/a> the very real likelihood is that next election that will just become an arms race,&#8221; he said.<\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div class=\"font-serif-text mb-12 leading-normal\">\n<p class=\"[&amp;_em]:font-serif-text-italic [&amp;_cite]:font-serif-text-italic\">The open letter warned this could lead to disillusionment and lower trust in democracy, and suggested setting up a dedicated select committee to tackle the problem and put solutions in place.<\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div class=\"font-serif-text mb-12 leading-normal\">\n<p class=\"[&amp;_em]:font-serif-text-italic [&amp;_cite]:font-serif-text-italic\">Geddis said while some would argue politicians should not be the ones designing electoral systems &#8211; &#8220;like allowing panel beaters to design intersections, they are going to do so with their own best interests in mind&#8221; &#8211; there was a need to get the problem fixed before the next election, leaving little time for a broader discussion.<\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div class=\"font-serif-text mb-12 leading-normal\">\n<p class=\"[&amp;_em]:font-serif-text-italic [&amp;_cite]:font-serif-text-italic\">&#8220;We&#8217;ve only got three years &#8230; if we get a Parliamentary select committee doing the thinking about it, it&#8217;ll help MPs come to realise what the best solution is rather than having an external examination which then has to go to Parliament.&#8221;<\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div class=\"font-serif-text mb-12 leading-normal\">\n<p class=\"[&amp;_em]:font-serif-text-italic [&amp;_cite]:font-serif-text-italic\">The letter suggested options for fixing the overhang problem:<\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div class=\"font-serif-text leading-normal [&amp;_li&gt;ol.list]:!mt-4 [&amp;_li&gt;ol.list]:!pb-0 [&amp;_li&gt;ul.list]:!mt-4 [&amp;_li&gt;ul.list]:!pb-0 [&amp;_li]:!mb-8 [&amp;_ol]:pb-4 [&amp;_ul]:pb-4\">\n<ul class=\"list [&amp;_em]:font-serif-text-italic [&amp;_cite]:font-serif-text-italic\">\n<li class=\"\"><strong class=\"font-serif-text-medium\">Add more list seats <\/strong>so that Parliament would get bigger, to make up for any overhang<\/li>\n<li class=\"\"><strong class=\"font-serif-text-medium\">Reduce the number of electorates<\/strong> which would reduce the number of possible overhang seats<\/li>\n<li class=\"\"><strong class=\"font-serif-text-medium\">Remove electorate seats from parties that win too many overhang seats<\/strong> by (in line with Germany) requiring parties to have enough party votes to cover their overhang wins, perhaps allowing one or two overhang seats per party<\/li>\n<li class=\"\"><strong class=\"font-serif-text-medium\">Only have one vote<\/strong>, so that electorate-based votes also count as party votes, electing both a local MP and contributing to a party vote that could bring in additional list MPs<\/li>\n<li class=\"\"><strong class=\"font-serif-text-medium\">Change how votes in Parliament work <\/strong>so that it&#8217;s based on the proportion of party vote, rather than the number of MPs<\/li>\n<\/ul>\n<\/div>\n<div class=\"font-serif-text mb-12 leading-normal\">\n<p class=\"[&amp;_em]:font-serif-text-italic [&amp;_cite]:font-serif-text-italic\">One campaign for such a strategy at the election led by billionaire Harry Mowbray explicitly aimed to undermine MMP, which he <a class=\"underline-brand-hover visited:text-foreground-secondary hover:visited:text-foreground-primary\" href=\"https:\/\/www.rnz.co.nz\/news\/politics_election-2026\/2235548\/harry-mowbray-s-split-your-vote-website-probed-by-electoral-commission\">called a &#8220;complete dog&#8221;<\/a> because it ensured power for minority voices.<\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div class=\"pb-16 pt-8\">\n<div class=\"grid justify-center\">\n<figure class=\"mx-auto table\">\n<div class=\"image-ring flex w-full max-w-full -mx-16 md:mx-0 w-screen border-x-0 !max-w-[initial] md:w-[revert-layer] md:!max-w-full [&amp;_img]:w-full [&amp;_img]:md:w-[revert-layer]\"><img loading=\"lazy\" decoding=\"async\" class=\"ml:max-h-[50rem] max-w-full aspect-[16\/10] object-cover\" src=\"https:\/\/media.rnztools.nz\/rnz\/image\/upload\/s--yiNgATA1--\/t_kt-crop-16x10\/w_614\/f_auto\/q_auto:eco\/4JFN04J_harry_mowbray_scaled_webp\" alt=\"Harry Mowbray was known as an organic dairy farmer, then as the patriarch of the billionaire Zuru family \u2013 and now finds himself a conservative political activist. Photo: Supplied\" width=\"614\" height=\"384\" \/><\/div><figcaption class=\"border-stroke-default w-full border-b py-12 text-sm *:inline table-caption caption-bottom mt-auto\">Harry Mowbray.<\/p>\n<p class=\"text-foreground-secondary flex-shrink-0 ml-4\">Supplied<\/p>\n<\/figcaption><\/figure>\n<\/div>\n<\/div>\n<div class=\"font-serif-text mb-12 leading-normal\">\n<p class=\"[&amp;_em]:font-serif-text-italic [&amp;_cite]:font-serif-text-italic\">However, Mowbray himself <a class=\"underline-brand-hover visited:text-foreground-secondary hover:visited:text-foreground-primary\" href=\"https:\/\/www.rnz.co.nz\/news\/politics\/2356865\/harry-mowbray-calls-coatesville-mansion-summit-to-get-rid-of-mmp\">preferred something resembling the supplementary member system<\/a>, which would be less representative and guarantee outsized influence from electorates.<\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div class=\"font-serif-text mb-12 leading-normal\">\n<p class=\"[&amp;_em]:font-serif-text-italic [&amp;_cite]:font-serif-text-italic\">&#8220;There&#8217;s an irony there,&#8221; Rashbrooke said, &#8220;that some of the people who are trying to engineer a situation where MMP becomes less proportional, and then argue that&#8217;s a weakness in the system, are also people who want an electoral system that is much less proportional than MMP.&#8221;<\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div class=\"font-serif-text mb-12 leading-normal\">\n<p class=\"[&amp;_em]:font-serif-text-italic [&amp;_cite]:font-serif-text-italic\">Geddis agreed.<\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div class=\"font-serif-text mb-12 leading-normal\">\n<p class=\"[&amp;_em]:font-serif-text-italic [&amp;_cite]:font-serif-text-italic\">&#8220;Harry Mowbray&#8217;s criticism of MMP seems slightly confused &#8230; he thinks it gives smaller parties too much power, and the way that he sought to undermine MMP was to show smaller parties how they could get more power.&#8221;<\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div class=\"font-serif-text mb-12 leading-normal\">\n<p class=\"[&amp;_em]:font-serif-text-italic [&amp;_cite]:font-serif-text-italic\">He said he was not sure such campaigns were successful, but the real risk was future elections would become less policy, more about tactical voting strategies.<\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div class=\"font-serif-text mb-12 leading-normal\">\n<p class=\"[&amp;_em]:font-serif-text-italic [&amp;_cite]:font-serif-text-italic\">&#8220;There&#8217;s no such thing as a perfect electoral system. There&#8217;s always going to be pros and cons to any change.&#8221;<\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div class=\"font-serif-text mb-12 leading-normal\">\n<p class=\"[&amp;_em]:font-serif-text-italic [&amp;_cite]:font-serif-text-italic\">The open letter also highlighted the three public referendums New Zealand had held on the electoral system &#8211; in 1992, &#8217;93 and 2011 &#8211; all favouring MMP.<\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div class=\"font-serif-text mb-12 leading-normal\">\n<p class=\"[&amp;_em]:font-serif-text-italic [&amp;_cite]:font-serif-text-italic\">Rashbrooke said there was no need to throw the proverbial baby out with the bathwater.<\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div class=\"font-serif-text mb-12 leading-normal\">\n<p class=\"[&amp;_em]:font-serif-text-italic [&amp;_cite]:font-serif-text-italic\">&#8220;The problem with any system other than MMP is it will be less proportional, it will do a worse job of translating what people actually want into seats in Parliament &#8230; we have discovered there is a weakness in it, that weakness needs to be fixed.<\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div class=\"font-serif-text mb-12 leading-normal\">\n<p class=\"[&amp;_em]:font-serif-text-italic [&amp;_cite]:font-serif-text-italic\">&#8220;A bit like the case of: you&#8217;ve got a perfectly solid house, it&#8217;s a really good house but you&#8217;ve just discovered that there&#8217;s a little vulnerability in it &#8230; something that needs to be patched up, something that needs to be mended &#8211; but the foundations are all totally secure.&#8221;<\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div class=\"pb-16 pt-8\">\n<div class=\"grid justify-center\">\n<figure class=\"mx-auto table\">\n<div class=\"image-ring flex w-full max-w-full -mx-16 md:mx-0 w-screen border-x-0 !max-w-[initial] md:w-[revert-layer] md:!max-w-full [&amp;_img]:w-full [&amp;_img]:md:w-[revert-layer]\"><img loading=\"lazy\" decoding=\"async\" class=\"ml:max-h-[50rem] max-w-full aspect-[16\/10] object-cover\" src=\"https:\/\/media.rnztools.nz\/rnz\/image\/upload\/s--viz3vgaF--\/t_kt-crop-16x10\/w_614\/f_auto\/q_auto:eco\/4JMVUT5_Max_Rashbrooke_4F0A0111_jpg\" alt=\"Writer and researcher Max Rashbrooke\" width=\"614\" height=\"384\" \/><\/div><figcaption class=\"border-stroke-default w-full border-b py-12 text-sm *:inline table-caption caption-bottom mt-auto\">Max Rashbrooke.<\/p>\n<p class=\"text-foreground-secondary flex-shrink-0 ml-4\">RNZ \/ Cole Eastham-Farrelly<\/p>\n<\/figcaption><\/figure>\n<\/div>\n<\/div>\n<div class=\"font-serif-text mb-12 leading-normal\">\n<p class=\"[&amp;_em]:font-serif-text-italic [&amp;_cite]:font-serif-text-italic\">An independent review following the 2011 referendum had also called for overhang seats to be abolished, and despite changes to the electoral system &#8211; including in both the most recent terms of Parliament, one led by National and one by Labour &#8211; politicians have never tackled that or a number of other recommendations.<\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div class=\"font-serif-text mb-12 leading-normal\">\n<p class=\"[&amp;_em]:font-serif-text-italic [&amp;_cite]:font-serif-text-italic\">Neither Geddis nor Rashbrooke believed the major parties could be blamed.<\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div class=\"font-serif-text mb-12 leading-normal\">\n<p class=\"[&amp;_em]:font-serif-text-italic [&amp;_cite]:font-serif-text-italic\">&#8220;The fixes that were proposed in the past were fixes for a much smaller problem that you know wasn&#8217;t quite as pressing. This time around, we can see what the problem is, we can see its magnitude, and we can predict that it&#8217;s likely to reoccur in the future,&#8221; Geddis said.<\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div class=\"font-serif-text mb-12 leading-normal\">\n<p class=\"[&amp;_em]:font-serif-text-italic [&amp;_cite]:font-serif-text-italic\">Rashbrooke pointed to the 1986 Royal Commission on Electoral Reform&#8217;s finding that &#8220;accidental deviations [from proportional results] are most unlikely, and that any attempt to deliberately manipulate the system would be both difficult to implement and likely to attract an electoral backlash&#8221;.<\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div class=\"font-serif-text mb-12 leading-normal\">\n<p class=\"[&amp;_em]:font-serif-text-italic [&amp;_cite]:font-serif-text-italic\">&#8220;I didn&#8217;t see this coming &#8230; it&#8217;s crept up upon us,&#8221; Rashbrooke said. &#8220;I&#8217;m not sure that I would blame anyone very strongly for not seeing that coming, I think the point is just now that the problem is staring us in the face. We have to do something about it.<\/p>\n<\/div>\n<div class=\"font-serif-text mb-12 leading-normal\">\n<p class=\"[&amp;_em]:font-serif-text-italic [&amp;_cite]:font-serif-text-italic\">&#8220;I suspect they didn&#8217;t think that it would be a problem &#8230; it&#8217;s not in the nature of the National Party to assume that they&#8217;re going to get a really low party vote and have a whole lot of overhang seats. You know, that&#8217;s not how National&#8217;s ego works, if you like.&#8221;<\/p>\n<\/div>\n<p>rnz<\/p>\n","protected":false},"excerpt":{"rendered":"<p>A group of 46 experts wants politicians to urgently consider improving the MMP electoral system, to avoid undemocratic elections in future. Their open letter &#8211; led by Andrew Geddis, Lara Greaves and Max Rashbrooke &#8211; is titled &#8220;Keep the &#8216;P&#8217; in MMP&#8221; and points to the 11-seat overhang indicated by the initial results putting the [&hellip;]<\/p>\n","protected":false},"author":6,"featured_media":18919,"comment_status":"open","ping_status":"open","sticky":false,"template":"","format":"standard","meta":{"footnotes":""},"categories":[222,174],"tags":[],"class_list":["post-18918","post","type-post","status-publish","format-standard","has-post-thumbnail","hentry","category-latest-news","category-nz-news"],"amp_enabled":true,"_links":{"self":[{"href":"https:\/\/thebuzz.apnanetwork.co.nz\/index.php?rest_route=\/wp\/v2\/posts\/18918","targetHints":{"allow":["GET"]}}],"collection":[{"href":"https:\/\/thebuzz.apnanetwork.co.nz\/index.php?rest_route=\/wp\/v2\/posts"}],"about":[{"href":"https:\/\/thebuzz.apnanetwork.co.nz\/index.php?rest_route=\/wp\/v2\/types\/post"}],"author":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/thebuzz.apnanetwork.co.nz\/index.php?rest_route=\/wp\/v2\/users\/6"}],"replies":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/thebuzz.apnanetwork.co.nz\/index.php?rest_route=%2Fwp%2Fv2%2Fcomments&post=18918"}],"version-history":[{"count":1,"href":"https:\/\/thebuzz.apnanetwork.co.nz\/index.php?rest_route=\/wp\/v2\/posts\/18918\/revisions"}],"predecessor-version":[{"id":18920,"href":"https:\/\/thebuzz.apnanetwork.co.nz\/index.php?rest_route=\/wp\/v2\/posts\/18918\/revisions\/18920"}],"wp:featuredmedia":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/thebuzz.apnanetwork.co.nz\/index.php?rest_route=\/wp\/v2\/media\/18919"}],"wp:attachment":[{"href":"https:\/\/thebuzz.apnanetwork.co.nz\/index.php?rest_route=%2Fwp%2Fv2%2Fmedia&parent=18918"}],"wp:term":[{"taxonomy":"category","embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/thebuzz.apnanetwork.co.nz\/index.php?rest_route=%2Fwp%2Fv2%2Fcategories&post=18918"},{"taxonomy":"post_tag","embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/thebuzz.apnanetwork.co.nz\/index.php?rest_route=%2Fwp%2Fv2%2Ftags&post=18918"}],"curies":[{"name":"wp","href":"https:\/\/api.w.org\/{rel}","templated":true}]}}